statistiche per siti

Falcone and Borsellino on Asinara: the summer of 1985 that prepared the Maxi Trial

In this article

Updated November 2026

In the summer of 1985, Falcone and Borsellino on Asinara were not on holiday. After the murders of the police officers Beppe Montana and Ninni Cassarà, the two Palermo investigating magistrates were moved with their families to the prison island for their own safety. They stayed in the guesthouse at Cala d’Oliva and spent about a month there working on the papers that, in November, would become the indictment for the Maxi Trial against the Sicilian Mafia.

For us, working every day in the waters of the National Park, Asinara is above all sea, white donkeys and coves. But it’s also an island that has held some heavy chapters of Italian history, and this is one that deserves to be told accurately and with respect.

In this article we set out what official sources and the testimony of those involved allow us to say with certainty: why they were brought here, who was with them, where they lived, what they wrote and what remains today at Cala d’Oliva. Where accounts differ, we tell you.

At a glance

  • When: August 1985, for about a month according to the Park authority.
  • Why: to protect them after the murders of Beppe Montana (28 July) and Ninni Cassarà (6 August), at the height of the investigation into Cosa Nostra.
  • Who: Giovanni Falcone and Paolo Borsellino with their families, including Francesca Morvillo, Agnese Borsellino and her three children.
  • Where: in the former guesthouse at Cala d’Oliva, the red house by the sea, now a station of the regional Forestry Corps.
  • What: work on the Maxi Trial investigation, whose indictment was filed on 8 November 1985.

Why Falcone and Borsellino were moved to Asinara

The summer of 1985 was brutal in Palermo. On 28 July the Mafia killed police commissioner Giuseppe “Beppe” Montana, head of the Flying Squad’s fugitive-hunting unit, at Porticello. Ten days later, on 6 August, deputy police chief Antonino “Ninni” Cassarà and officer Roberto Antiochia were murdered on Viale Croce Rossa. Cassarà was a close colleague of Giovanni Falcone, as the Italian State Police recalls in its page on the officers killed that summer (in Italian).

The anti-Mafia pool of Palermo’s investigating office, led by Antonino Caponnetto, was completing the largest investigation ever carried out against Cosa Nostra. The risk of an attack on the magistrates was considered real. Years later, Caponnetto said that the real reason for the move was a specific warning, kept confidential at the time, and that the departure was arranged with the utmost urgency.

They needed somewhere far from Palermo and hard to reach. Asinara, at the time entirely run by the prison administration and closed to the public, fitted the bill. As the Park authority notes, its extreme security measures made it suitable for housing the two magistrates temporarily.

Who was on Asinara in the summer of 1985

They didn’t go alone. With Paolo Borsellino were his wife Agnese and their children Lucia, Manfredi and Fiammetta. With Giovanni Falcone was Francesca Morvillo, herself a magistrate, and, according to the Borsellino family’s recollections, her mother too.

Lucia Borsellino, a teenager at the time, has described the journey: the destination revealed only during the flight, landing in Sardinia and then crossing to the island in a prison service motorboat. In those years, the only people living on Asinara were the guards and their families, the prison staff and the inmates.

The rocky coast of Asinara seen from the sea
Asinara from the sea: in 1985 the island was closed to the public and could only be reached on prison service boats.

Falcone and Borsellino’s house at Cala d’Oliva: the guesthouse

The correct name of the building is the one the Park authority uses: the former Guesthouse (Ex Foresteria) of Cala d’Oliva. The families and the press remember it as the “red house” or the “little red villa”: a building facing the sea on the edge of the village that was then the heart of the penal colony.

What the Park authority says

On its page on the history of Asinara, the National Park states that in 1985 the two magistrates stayed with their families for about a month at the former Guesthouse of Cala d’Oliva, which is now a station of the Sardinia Region’s Forestry Corps.

A single-storey red house above the rocks and sea at Cala d'Oliva, seen from a terrace in the village
The red house by the sea at Cala d'Oliva, the former guesthouse where Falcone and Borsellino stayed in 1985 (photo from 2006). Photo: Felisopus, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Cala d’Oliva was no ordinary place. It was home to the Central Branch of the penal colony, the largest village on the prison island. If you’d like to understand how the village was organised, see our article on Cala d’Oliva and the bunker.

How long the stay on Asinara lasted

Sources don’t fully agree on how long it lasted, and we’d rather say so. The Park authority speaks of about a month. Caponnetto, and Borsellino himself in a 1992 television interview, placed the stay in August, until the end of the month.

Borsellino’s children, in their more recent accounts, remember a longer stay for part of the family: Lucia and Fiammetta went back to Palermo earlier, while their father is said to have stayed on the island with his wife and Manfredi until early October. The exact arrival and departure dates therefore remain uncertain.

What they wrote on the island: the Maxi Trial investigation

The first days were the hardest. According to later recollections, when they arrived the two magistrates had no case files and had to wait for the documents to come from Palermo. Those who were with them remember them as impatient to get back to work.

Once the papers arrived, work resumed at a relentless pace, late into the night. This was the final phase of the investigation that led to the committal order (ordinanza-sentenza), signed by the investigating office and filed on 8 November 1985. The case went down in history under the name of the first defendant in alphabetical order: “Abbate Giovanni + 706”.

The Maxi Trial was built on that document. It opened on 10 February 1986 in the bunker courtroom built inside the Ucciardone prison complex in Palermo. The first-instance trial ended on 16 December 1987 with 19 life sentences. On 30 January 1992, the Court of Cassation upheld the prosecution’s case.

Hills covered in Mediterranean scrub sloping down to the sea on the Asinara coast
The hills of Asinara: a landscape of great beauty that, in the summer of 1985, was the backdrop to weeks of work.

The bill for the stay: a documented episode

Once the emergency was over, the two magistrates were asked to pay for their stay: board and lodging for themselves and their families. Paolo Borsellino told the story himself in a 1992 interview with the journalist Lamberto Sposini. He explained that the amounts weren’t excessive, but that he hadn’t thought it fair.

Caponnetto spoke about it too, and later so did Borsellino’s children, who remember their father telling the story with irony. We won’t add figures: press accounts report different amounts, and the point of the episode doesn’t change.

Key timeline: Falcone, Borsellino and Asinara

Here are the main dates, checked against institutional and press sources. For the stay itself we give only the month, as sources don’t agree on the days.

Date What happened
1885 Parliament approves an agricultural penal colony and a lazaretto on Asinara: the inhabitants are moved off the island.
1970s The prison is expanded and some branches become a maximum-security prison.
28 July 1985 Police commissioner Beppe Montana is murdered at Porticello.
6 August 1985 Ninni Cassarà and officer Roberto Antiochia are murdered in Palermo.
August 1985 Falcone and Borsellino are moved with their families to Asinara, to the Cala d’Oliva guesthouse, for about a month.
8 November 1985 The Maxi Trial committal order is filed.
10 February 1986 The Maxi Trial opens in the Ucciardone bunker courtroom.
16 December 1987 First-instance verdict, with 19 life sentences.
30 January 1992 The Court of Cassation upholds the convictions.
23 May and 19 July 1992 The Capaci and Via D’Amelio bombings.
1997 Asinara National Park is established.
4–5 October 2025 Forty years on, the Italian National Association of Magistrates marks the stay with two days of events on the island, attended by Lucia and Manfredi Borsellino.

The link with Asinara’s prison history and Fornelli

The magistrates’ stay only makes sense within the island’s long history as a place of detention. From 1885 Asinara was an agricultural penal colony, divided into about ten branches spread across the island. From the 1970s some facilities were turned into a maximum-security prison, holding members of Cosa Nostra, the Camorra, terrorist groups and Sardinian banditry.

The best-known facility of that period is the Fornelli maximum-security prison, in the south of the island, about 25 kilometres by road from Cala d’Oliva. We tell its story in Fornelli: history and secrets of the supercarcere. There’s a paradox that strikes visitors to the island: the same security system designed to hold the bosses served, for a few weeks, to protect the magistrates who were bringing them to trial.

The prison was gradually closed, partly after protests from the local community, and in 1997 the National Park was created. For the full picture, from the beginnings to today, see our guide to the history of Asinara. And if you’re curious about the exodus of 1885 that led to the founding of our village, read the history of Stintino.

Donkeys grazing along the Asinara coast, seen from above
Asinara's donkeys along the coast: today the island is a National Park open to visitors.

What you can see at Cala d’Oliva today

The guesthouse still stands, but it isn’t a house museum: according to the Park authority, it’s now a station of the Sardinia Region’s Forestry Corps. You can see it from the outside, with the respect owed to a building in use and to what it represents.

A plaque on the building carries two quotations. One is from Borsellino: “Those who are afraid die every day; those who are not afraid die only once.” The other is from Falcone: “The Mafia is by no means invincible: it is a human phenomenon, and like all human phenomena it has a beginning and will also have an end.”

In the village of Cala d’Oliva, the former Central Branch now houses the Park’s Memory Observatory (Osservatorio della Memoria). Walking through the streets you can still make out the buildings of daily life back then, now mostly empty: the infirmary, the school, the dairy, the carpentry workshop, even a small cinema. Other places not to miss on the island are gathered in our guide to what to see on Asinara.

Silvia’s tip

If this story interests you, visit Cala d’Oliva with one of the Park’s licensed guides. They’ll help you read the village and its buildings, which say little on their own. And take a moment in front of the red house, without hurrying: it’s a place best understood in silence.

Crystal-clear water over a deep seabed along the Asinara coast
The sea around Asinara: to visit the island, it's best to rely on the Park's licensed operators and guides.

How to get to Cala d’Oliva

Cala d’Oliva is on the east coast of Asinara, in the north of the island. You can get there on trips run by the Park’s licensed operators or with the hire vehicles available on the island. Ferry times, boarding points and ways of visiting are covered in our guide on how to visit Asinara.

Falcone and Borsellino on Asinara: FAQ

Where did Falcone and Borsellino stay on Asinara?

In the former guesthouse at Cala d’Oliva, the red house overlooking the sea. Today the building is a station of the Sardinia Region’s Forestry Corps.

Why did Falcone and Borsellino go to Asinara?

For security reasons, after the murders of Beppe Montana and Ninni Cassarà in the summer of 1985. On the island, then a maximum-security prison, they were able to continue their work on the Maxi Trial.

How long did they stay on the island?

About a month in August 1985, according to the Park authority. Some family accounts mention a longer stay for part of the Borsellino family.

Can you visit Falcone and Borsellino’s house?

You can see it from the outside at Cala d’Oliva, but it isn’t a house museum. There’s a plaque on the building with two quotations from the magistrates.

Is it true they paid the bill for their stay?

Yes. Paolo Borsellino told the story himself in 1992: he said the sum wasn’t excessive, but that he hadn’t thought it fair.

Asinara from the sea. With Davide and Silvia you’ll sail along the Park’s coast aboard the fishing boat Alex, with pot fishing, coves and a stop ashore at Cala Reale → book your day.

Picture of Davide e Silvia

Davide e Silvia

Pescatori professionisti di Stintino. Ogni giorno, a bordo della Motopesca Alex, salpiamo le nasse nel Golfo dell'Asinara e raccontiamo ai nostri ospiti il mare, la pesca artigianale e le tradizioni di questa costa.

In this article
Go fishing tourism around Asinara

A full day on board the fishing boat Alex: pot fishing, swims in the coves of the National Park and lunch made with the catch of the day. Maximum 12 guests.

Keep reading

Live the sea

Come aboard with Davide and Silvia

Real pot fishing, the most beautiful coves of Asinara National Park and lunch on board with the catch of the day.